Conscience Against Ideological Memory: Re-Reading the “Three Obediences and Four Virtues” in Han China Through Ethico-Political Responsibility
Keywords:
Conscience, Ethical Responsibility, Gender, Han Dynasty, Ideological Memory, Moral Agency, Three Obediences and Four Virtues, Women in Han ChinaAbstract
The notion of San cong si de (Three Obediences and Four Virtues) has frequently been regarded as a paradigmatic expression of the subordination and inferior status of women in traditional Chinese society. This interpretation has become particularly influential in modern discussions of gender and Confucian ethics. Yet the historical evidence from the Han dynasty presents a considerably more complex picture. This article rereads the “Three Obediences and Four Virtues” through the interconnected concepts of conscience, responsibility, moral agency and ethico-political imagination. It argues that the subsequent memory of these norms can become ideologically selective when a historically differentiated system of social and familial responsibilities is reduced to the binary categories of oppression and liberation. The original framework undoubtedly contained a male-centred hierarchy and did not establish gender equality in political, economic, educational or public life. At the same time, Han sources reveal women exercising moral judgment and counsel, participating in economic production, influencing familial and political affairs, receiving education, making choices concerning marriage and assuming significant responsibility for the moral formation of children and the well-being of the household. The “Three Obediences,” therefore, should be examined not merely as prescriptions of passive submission, but also in relation to social position, relational dependence, reciprocal responsibility and the ethical obligations embedded in familial relationships. Particular attention is given to the capacity of wives to counsel their husbands, mothers to shape the moral character of their sons, women to participate in productive labour, and women to exercise a degree of agency in matters of marriage. These instances reveal forms of responsible dissent that need not entail a rejection of tradition but may instead arise from within its moral framework. The article argues that responsible historical interpretation requires moving beyond polarized memories of tradition and recovering the internal complexity of inherited ethical systems. Such a rereading neither denies the hierarchical dimensions of Han gender ethics nor romanticizes its social order; rather, it demonstrates how conscience and responsibility could operate within a differentiated structure of social relations and how the remembrance and interpretation of historical traditions themselves entail an ethical responsibility.
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Journal of Dharma

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.