DIALOGUE WITH ISLAM
Ecclesiam Suam – Pushing out the Boat
Keywords:
Catholic, Dialogue, Ecclesiam Suam, Magisterium, Muslim, Paul VI, PersonalismAbstract
I will touch on two issues in this paper: first, the meaning and ambiguity of the word ‘dialogue’ and how it has caused problems in actual interreligious ‘dialogue’ with Islam; and second, and more substantially, I shall offer some thoughts on the doctrinal achievements of Ecclesiam Suam and the Council’s teachings on Islam and some subsequent developments. This is because I am convinced that the doctrinal achievements are central for mapping out the future possibilities of Catholic-Muslim dialogue. There are of course many other topics that one could speak of in Catholic-Muslim relations: most importantly the richness of spiritual exchange between these traditions;1 or sadly, the murdering of each other in some parts of the world, or the denial of free practice of religion by Muslims towards Catholics and Christians in parts of the world, or happily, the remarkable socio-political cooperation between Catholics and Muslims when faced with pressing and often tragic social problems. But I will focus on the theological-doctrinal issues for the reason given.
References
See the excellent survey until 2000: Michael Fitzgerald, “Christian Muslim Dialogue - A Survey of Recent Developments,” 10 April 2000 <http://sedosmission.org/old/eng/fitzgerald.htm> and with some contentious exegesis of Lumen Gentium, but otherwise most helpfully: Douglas Pratt, “The Vatican in Dialogue with Islam: inclusion and engagement,” Islam and Christian-Muslim Relations, 21, 2010, 245-62.
Karim Lahham, The Roman Catholic Church’s Position on Islam after Vatican II, Tabah Papers Series, Number 2, Abu Dhabi: UAE, 2008.
Mahmoud Ayoub, “Pope John Paul on Islam,” in John Paul II and Interreligious Dialogue, eds. Byron L. Sherwin and Harold Kasimow, Maryknoll, N.Y.: Orbis Books, 1999, 171–86, 174.
Henning Wrogemann, Missionarischer Islam und gesellschaftlicher Dialog: Eine Studie zur Begründung und Praxis des Aufrufs zum Islam, Verlag Otto Lembeck, Frankfurt, 2006.
Joseph Kenny OP, Views on Christian-Muslim Relations, Ch. 2, <http://www.crvp.org/book/Series02/IIA-13/chapter__two.htm> (18 May 2014);
Francis Sullivan, Salvation Outside the Church? Tracing the History of the Catholic Response, London: Geoffrey Chapman, 1992, 187-88
Ann Michele Nolan, A Privileged Moment: Dialogue in the Language of the Second Vatican Council 1962-65, Berlin: Peter Lang, 2006.
Anthony M Barratt, in Heythrop Journal 49.5, 2008, 889-890.
William Burrows, The Roman Catholic Magisterium on Other Religious Ways: Analysis and Critique from a Postmodern Perspective, Chicago: University of Chicago, 1987.
Jacques Maritain, Redeeming the Time, London: Geoffrey Bles, 1943, 108-09.
“Reflection on Vatican II (Part 4),” 22 February 2013: <http://www.zenit.org/en/articles/pope-s-reflectionon-vatican-ii-part-4> (8 May 2014).
Francesco DeGoia, ed., Interreligious Dialogue: the Official Teaching of the Catholic Church from the Second Vatican Council to John Paul II (1963-2005), Boston: Pauline Books & Media, 2006, 159.
Stephen Bullivant, “Sine Culpa. Vatican II and Inculpable Ignorance,” Theological Studies, 72, 2011, 70-86.
<http://www.basilica.org/pages/ebooks/Msgr.%20Hagan-The %20Catechism%20of%20Saint%20Pope%20Pius%20X.pdf (11 March 2014).
Andrew Unsworth, A Historical and Textual-Critical Analysis of the Magisterial Documents of the Catholic Church on Islam: Towards a Heterodescriptive Account of Muslim Belief and Practice, Doctoral Dissertation, London: Heythrop College, 2007.
Gregory VII, Letter III, 21 to Anazir [Al-Nasir], King of Mauretania PL, 148.451A;
“Vatican Council And Papal Statements On Islam” (May 2014): <http://www.usccb.org/beliefs- and-teachings/ecumenical-and-interreligious/interreligious/islam/ vatican-council-and-papal-statements-on-islam.cfm (1 May 2014).
Jean Daniélou, God and the Ways of Knowing, Cleavland, Ohio: Meridian Books, 1957.
Riccardo Lombardi, The Salvation of the Unbeliever, trans., Dorothy M. White, London: Burns & Oates, 1956.
Mikka Ruokanen, Catholic Doctrine of Non-Christian Religions: According to the Second Vatican Council, Leiden: Brill, 1992, 77; and D’Costa, The Meeting of the Religions and the Trinity, New York: Orbis Books, 2000, 102-03.
Gavin D’Costa, Vatican II: Catholic Doctrines on Jews and Muslims, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014, 178-210.
David Marshall, "Roman Catholic Approaches to the Qur'an since Vatican II," Islam and Christian–Muslim Relations, 25:1, 2014, 89-100;
Muhammad: "Muhammad in Contemporary Christian Theological Reflection, Islam and Christian– Muslim Relations," 24:2, 2013, 161-172. ]
Christian W. Troll, "Changing Catholic views of Islam" in Jacques Waardenburg, ed., Islam and Christianity: Mutual Perceptions since the Mid 20th Century, Leuven: Peeters Press, 1998, 19–77.
Francesco Goia, ed., Interreligious Dialogue: The Official Teaching of the Catholic Church from the Second Vatican Council to John Paul II (1963–1995), Boston: Pauline Books & Media, 1997.
Thomas Michel, S. J., "Where to Now? Ways forward for Interreligious Dialogue: Images of Abraham as Models of Interreligious Encounter," The Muslim World, 100, 4, 2010, 530–538.
F. E. Peters, The Children of Abraham: Judaism, Christianity, Islam, A New Edition, Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2004.
<https://w2.vatican.va/content/john-paulii/en/speeches/2001/may/documents/hf_jpii_spe_20010506_omayya di.html (1 May 2014).
John Paul II, Crossing the Threshold of Hope, London: Jonathan Cape, 1994, 92.
