IDENTITY, ALTERITY AND SOCIAL MEDIA

Coercing Silence

Authors

  • Richard Rego St Joseph's College Autonomous

Keywords:

Alterity, Dissent, Identity, Narendra Modi, Rajdeep Sardesai, Social Media, Troll, Twitter

Abstract

With the advent of social media and digital imaginaries, the right-wing cultural politics has taken the centre-stage in India's popular imagination. On this digital landscape, images are manipulated to create identities, thereby othering the self and producing alterity. Digital India, which was launched to wire the nation, has paved the way for digital imaginary, and has become a contested site which dominates the public discourse by displaying right-wing political power and a cultural nationalism as defined by groups owing allegiance to the ruling dispensation. Instead of providing an even-playing field for a multiplicity of identities, the digital imaginary has endangered identities. Social media platforms like Twitter and Facebook are used to shame and silence non-conformists to alienate and subjugate, thus othering the self. Within the theoretical framework of discourse analysis, this article examines tweets posted by trolls to name and shame the other to create alterities. Using a case-study of television journalist Rajdeep Sardesai, who for a while quit Twitter owing to attacks on him by trolls, it argues that the online space is a pliable domain on which dominant voices create identities and alterities to suit their agenda. It concludes that images are used to create fake identities along religio-nationalist ideologies, and hate speech and propaganda devices employed to other the self and create alterities.

Author Biography

Richard Rego, St Joseph's College Autonomous

Dr Richard Rego, Associate Professor of Mass Communication in the Department of Communication, St Joseph's College Autonomous, Bengaluru, teaches Film Studies, Indian Cinema, and journalism. His research interests include film studies, journalism, social media discourses, and community radio.

References

Twitter, "Tweets still must flow," Twitter, 26 Jan. 2012 (15 August 2016).

Scroll Staff, "Rajdeep Sardesai announces Twitter 'detox break' citing character assassination, slander," scroll.in (30 April 2016) <http://scroll.in/article/807434/rajdeep-sardesai-announces-twitterdetox-break-citing-character-assassination-slander> (15 May 2016).

Jamie Bartlett, Richard Norrie, Sofia Patel, Rebekka Rumpel, Simon Wibberley, Misogyny on Twitter, London: Demos, 2014, 3.

Ashley Esarey and Xiao Qiang, "Political Expression in the Chinese Blogsphere: Below the Radar," Asian Survey, 48:5 (Oct. 2008), 752-772 (13 August 2016).

Brian D. Loader and Dan Mercea, "Networking Democracy? Social Media Innovations in Participatory Politics," Information, Communication & Society, 14: 6, (2011), 757-769

Dave Carter, "'Digital democracy' or 'information aristocracy'? Economic regeneration and the information economy," in, The Governance of Cyberspace: Politics, Technology and Global Restructuring, ed. Brian D. Loader, London: Routledge, 1997, 133-49.

Clay Shirky, "The Political Power of Social Media - Technology, the Public Sphere, and Political Change," Foreign Affairs, (Jan/Feb. 2011) <https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/2010-12-20/politicalpower-social-media> (14 June 2016).

Lawrence Liang, "Censorship and the Politics of Micro-Fascism," Television & New Media, 16:4, (2015), 388-393 (10 August 2016).

Bartlett and others, Misogyny on Twitter, London: Demos, 2014, 114 (20 June 2016).

Narendra Modi, "Shri Narendra Modi shares his vision for Digital India" <http://www.narendramodi.in/shri-narendra-modi-shareshis- vision-for-digital-india-5944> (02 July 2016).

Bonnie Nardi and Young Ming Kow, "Digital Imaginaries: How we know what we (think we) know about Chinese gold farming" First Monday, 15:6-7 (2010) <http://firstmonday.org/ojs/index.php/fm/ article/view/3035/2566#authorhttp://firstmonday.org/ojs/index.php/fm/article/view/3035/2566 > (15 August 2017).

Vinod K. Jose, "The Emperor Uncrowned - The rise of Narendra Modi," The Caravan, 01 March 2012 <http://www.caravanmagazine.in/ reportage/emperor-uncrowned-narendra-modi-profile> (2 July 2016).

Debarshi Dasgupta, “Shiva’s Tridents - Abrasive, savvy, rightwing, ubiquitous - they're 'Internet Hindus',” Outlook (19 Nov. 2012) <http://www.outlookindia.com/article.aspx?282925> (5 March 2014).

Rajiv Srivastava and Arjumand Bano, "Will take a 56-inch chest to turn UP into Gujarat, Modi to Mulayam," The Times of India, (24 Jan. 2014) <http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Will-take-a-56-inchchest-to-turn-UP-into-Gujarat-Modi-to-Mulayam/articleshow/292693 42.cms> (23 June 2016).

Sriram Mohan, "Locating the "Internet Hindu": Political Speech and Performance in Indian Cyberspace," Television & New Media, 16:4 (2015): 339-345

Ruchi Bambha, "Five things to know about Agusta Westland VVIP chopper scam," The Economic Times, (28 Jun. 2016, updated 11 Jul. 2018) <http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/defence/fivethings-to-know-about-agustawestland-vvip-chopperscam/articleshow/51992563.cms> (5 July 2016). Mohammed U. Shaikh, "Agusta Westland scam: Finmeccanica invited Indian journalists on a fully paid tour to Italy," India.com, (27 Apr. 2016), <http://www.india.com/ news/india/agusta-westland-scam-finmeccanica-invited-indian-journ alists-on-a-fully-paid-tour-to-italy-1142753/> (1 June 2016).

Mail Today Bureau, "Businessman and alleged 'middle-man' Christian Michel was paid Rs 50 crore by Agusta Westland to 'manage' the Indian Journalists and media," MailOnlineIndia, (28 Apr. 2016), <http://www.dailymail.co.uk/indiahome/article-3564532/ Businessman-alleged-middle-man-Christian-Michel-paid-Rs-50-croreAgustaWestland-manage-Indian-journalists-media.html> (1 June 2016).

Sandipan Sharma, "Rajdeep Sardesai's Twitter walkout is victory for sanskari trolls," Forstpost, (02 May 2016), <http://www.firstpost .com/india/rajdeep-sardesais-desperate-twitter-walkout-is-victoryfor- sanskari-trolls-2758314.html> (24 June 2016). Hemani Bhandari, "Finally, Twitter trolls got to @sardesairajdeep," Indian Express, (01 May 2016), <http://indianexpress.com/article/trending/trending-in-india/rajde ep-sardesai-quit-twitter-abusive-dms-2778117/> (24 June 2016). Ayub Dawood, "After Abusive DMs From His Handle, Rajdeep Sardesai Deletes Twitter Account," Scoopwhoop.com, (30 April 2016), (2 July 2016).

Julius Yourman, "Propaganda Techniques within Nazi Germany," Journal of Educational Sociology, 13:3, (Nov. 1939): 148-163, 149, <https://blog.uvm.edu/acmyers/files/2013/04/Propaganda-Techni ques.pdf> (20 June 2016).

Tom Stafford, BBC, "How liars create the 'illusion of truth'," 26 Oct. 2016 (15 August 2017).

Christophe Jaffrelot, "Communal Riots in Gujarat: The State at Risk?" Heidelberg Papers in South Asian and Comparative Politics, Working Paper No. 17. University of Heidelberg: South Asia Institute, Department of Political Science, 2003, <http://archiv.ub.uni-heidel berg.de/volltextserver/4127/1/hpsacp17.pdf> (5 June 2016).

BBC, "Gujarat riot death toll revealed," BBC News, (11 May 2005), <http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/4536199.stm> (5 June 2016).

Karan Thapar "Narendra Modi: Hindu leader abruptly ends TV interview after being quizzed," IBNLive.com, (06 June 2010), <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WKN_3lLULpY>(2 June 2016).

India Today, (28 Sept. 2014), (10 June 2016).

Felix De Silva and Martin Engelin, "Troll Detection : A Comparative Study in Detecting Troll Farms on Twitter Using Cluster Analysis," KTH Royal Institute of Technology, School of Computer Science and Communication, (2016) <https://kth.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:927209/FULLTEXT02.pdf> (2 June 2016).

Kirsti K. Cole, "It's like she's eager to be verbally abused: Twitter, trolls, and (en)gendering disciplinary rhetoric," Feminist Media Studies, 15:2 (2015): 356-358 (17 July 2016).

Kamayani, "NWMI demands end to online abuse of Ravish Kumar and protection for journalists," Kractivism, (28 May 2018) <http://www.kractivist.org/nwmi-demands-end-to-online-abuse-ofravish-kumar-and-protection-for-journalists/> (30 June 2018).

Caravan News, "Barkha Dutt Threatened; Rana Ayyub, Ravish Kumar Have Already Received Threats," The Caravan, (07 June 2018), <https://caravandaily.com/portal/barkha-dutt-threatened-rana-ayy ub -ravish-kumar-have-already-received-threats/> (10 June 2018).

Christopher Simpson, "Elisabeth Noelle-Neumann's 'spiral of silence' and the historical context of communication theory," Journal of Communication 46:3 (Summer 1996): 149-73 <https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1460-2466.1996.tb01494.x> (31 July 2016).

Jack M. Balkin, "Digital speech and democratic culture: a theory of freedom of expression for the information society," New York University Law Review. 79:1 (2004), Faculty Scholarship Series Paper 240 <http://digitalcommons.law.yale.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=12 39&context=fss_papers> (23 June 2016).

Downloads

Published

2018-03-29

How to Cite

Rego, R. (2018). IDENTITY, ALTERITY AND SOCIAL MEDIA: Coercing Silence. Journal of Dharma, 43(1), 85–110. Retrieved from https://dvkjournals.in/index.php/jd/article/view/239